Progressive Indiana Network: https://progressiveindiana.net
HoosLeft: https://hoosleft.us
Nick Neal: https://www.votenickneal.com/
SUMMARY:
Checking in on his home turf, Scott — who still calls the 219 area code home nearly 30 years after leaving — sits down with Nick Neal, Democratic candidate for Indiana House District 19 covering southern Lake and Porter counties. Neal, the son of a union U.S. Steel worker, spent the early part of his career as a Hammond police officer before moving into social services, where he now serves as VP of Community Services at Geminus Corporation, covering 12 counties in child abuse prevention, domestic violence intervention, foster care, and truancy work. The conversation ranges from his own union upbringing to the USW Local 7-1 lockout at BP Whiting, the real-world damage of Senate Bill 1’s property tax cuts to local schools, a nuanced take on “defund the police” from someone who’s worn the badge, and a clear-eyed account of what he’s hearing at the doors — from a lifelong Republican furious about the Iran war to a voter who wants a third party that — at least on this year’s ballot — doesn’t yet exist.
WHAT’S INSIDE:
00:00:23 Introduction: Nick Neal for Statehouse District 19
- Scott introduces Nick Neal: grew up in Gary with a father who worked at U.S. Steel, graduated Andrean High School, earned both degrees from IU Northwest, spent nearly two decades in Lake and Porter counties first as a police officer and then as a nonprofit leader focused on child abuse prevention, truancy, and domestic violence. He’s running for Statehouse District 19.
00:02:00 Support the Show
- HoosLeft and Progressive Indiana Network don’t paywall content or charge candidates — support at progressiveindiana.net sustains the project.
- Social handles: @hoosleft.us on Bluesky, Instagram, and Threads; @HoosLeft on Facebook, TikTok, and YouTube; PIN is @PINIndiana on Bluesky and TikTok, @progressiveindiananetwork on all the rest.
00:03:01 Welcome: Nick Neal and a Day Job Covering 12 Counties
- Neal is VP for Community Services at Geminus Corporation, a social service organization doing child abuse prevention, intervention, domestic violence casework, and foster care work. He currently covers 12 counties: Lake, Porter, LaPorte, Newton, Benton, Stark, Pulaski, Jasper, St. Joe, Elkhart, Kosciusko, and Marshall.
- He’s also been an adjunct criminal justice instructor at Indiana Wesleyan for 15 years and was a police officer earlier in his career. He decided to run because he believes it’s time for better representation in District 19 and across the state.
00:05:45 Growing Up in a Union Household
- Neal’s father worked doubles at the mill and also worked hospital security for almost 20 years. Neal describes the camaraderie of his father’s coworkers as an extended family, and remembers a period when the union had to fight for a contract.
- That hard-work ethic put Neal through junior high, high school, college, and grad school. His framing on bootstraps: current policy is cutting off people’s ankles and legs while still telling them to keep up and pull themselves up.
00:08:32 USW Local 7-1, Senate Bill 1, and the Child Care Voucher Freeze
- USW Local 7-1 has been locked out since March; Neal is partnering with Hobart Township Trustee Ericka McCauley and Lake County Recorder (soon to be Auditor) Gina Pimentel on a book bag drive and family meal support for affected workers.
- He pivots to Senate Bill 1’s impact on public education funding: Crown Point Schools alone face a $6.3 million reduction in their 2027 budget, on top of a million-plus already cut — hitting janitorial services, daily operations, teacher staffing, and class sizes in communities people move to specifically for the schools.
- He also flags the state’s CCDF child care voucher program, which was frozen for a year under the current administration only to be restored three months ago with a $20 million influx — after daycares closed and grandparents were forced into unplanned caregiving roles.
00:12:59 Redistricting and 20 Years of One-Party Rule in Indianapolis
- Neal notes Republicans have controlled the governor’s office, attorney general, secretary of state, and both legislative chambers (a 70-30 House split, 40-10 Senate) for roughly two decades — meaning every law passed comes from one party. He connects this to the state spending $7-11 million on mid-decade redistricting aimed partly at incumbents who didn’t vote for it, and warns Indiana’s congressional delegation could go from 7-2 to 9-0 by targeting Representatives Frank Mrvan and André Carson.
00:13:52 Voting Against Your Own Interest: Union Support for Republicans
- Scott asks why trade union voters increasingly back Republicans despite policies working against them. Neal’s read: a lack of political education, viral misinformation (including AI-generated content), and the human tendency not to engage until an issue is at your own front door.
- He describes low turnout at town halls and community conversations compared to the reach of a two-minute TikTok, true or not, and stresses that no income level is exempt from needing help — he’s seen people making a quarter million dollars and people making $10,000 both need assistance.
00:18:02 Soured on Democracy: Turnout, Gerrymandering, and ‘South of 30’
- Scott asks whether disengagement reflects lost faith that voting changes anything. Neal confirms hearing this directly, citing roughly 10% primary turnout in Lake County (some precincts as high as 15%) in an off-year election with no presidential race.
- Neal’s own district was redrawn in 2020’s gerrymander to be primarily Republican despite Lake County’s strong Democratic lean overall. Scott frames it as classic packing-and-cracking, and notes the demographic makeup of different parts of The Region: “North of 30, it’s all concrete. South of 30, you might as well be in Alabama.”
00:21:18 From Beat Cop in Hammond to a Career Change
- Neal worked as a Hammond police officer after college, calling it a formative and enjoyable experience with a genuinely good department culture — he says he never personally encountered the kind of toxic policing culture that makes headlines elsewhere, though he understands how it happens. He left to pursue further education and career growth, landing where he is today.
00:22:57 Defund the Police: What the Slogan Got Wrong
- Neal is direct: don’t defund the police, and he thinks the slogan itself was poorly chosen. What has actually helped, in his view, are social workers embedded in police departments handling mobile crisis response — something he’s seen work reasonably well locally.
- He distinguishes his own approach from a “punk” who becomes a “punk police officer” — the job doesn’t change your underlying character, and hiring boards can only weed out so much. He credits the broader movement with pushing useful reforms even if the specific slogan missed the mark.
00:27:11 ICE’s Hiring Spree, Local Policing, and Merrillville Pushing Back
- Scott contrasts community policing standards with ICE’s rapid hiring surge and lower vetting bar. Neal separates the two entirely, telling people frustrated with ICE bluntly: you get what you voted for — noting that in mixed political groups, someone complaining about ICE often voted for the party currently running it.
- He cites two or three killings by unqualified ICE agents and stresses that federal immigration enforcement actively undermines local and state police authority — and that when ICE leaves, it’s the local department left holding public anger for policies it didn’t create. Merrillville is actively pushing back against a proposed ICE detention center, with the state attorney threatening a lawsuit against the town; Neal notes local police are also privately unhappy, since federal overreach makes their job harder and threatens funding for jurisdictions seen as uncooperative.
00:32:01 Prevention Work: How Geminus Reaches Families Before a Crisis
- Geminus works with families through DCS on a voluntary, non-mandatory basis — case management, parenting education, therapeutic services, and budgetary help with rent and utilities — typically a fast 90-day program aimed at preventing removal.
- Other programs include one of only two certified batterer intervention programs in Lake County (a 26-week curriculum), extended foster care support through age 23, truancy programming, and services helping fathers establish paternity and reconnect with their children. Families find Geminus through DCS, schools, hospital referrals, and community events like book bag giveaways with free haircuts and food trucks.
00:35:05 Rising Need and Fixing Problems Upstream
- Need has risen sharply — NIPSCO bills that used to run $800-900 now reach $2,000, and Neal has to ration assistance across families because helping one fully means helping fewer others. One-bedroom apartments in the area run $1,400-1,500, on top of security deposits.
- Scott and Neal agree the fundamental problem is upstream: government policy, especially out of Indianapolis, is creating the very crises groups like Geminus then have to triage, when investment earlier would be both cheaper and more humane.
00:37:38 If Democrats Win the Statehouse: Repeal Senate Bill 1 First
- Asked what Democrats should prioritize if they retake the statehouse, Neal starts with repealing Senate Bill 1, tying it directly to affordability alongside the Medicaid waiver waitlist (11,000 people) and the child care voucher freeze. His broader critique: government keeps stopping programs “cold turkey” — Obamacare repeal with no replacement, the voucher freeze with no real fix — without a transition plan, then blaming the resulting chaos on the system itself.
00:41:59 The Property Tax Math That Doesn’t Add Up
- Neal breaks down the actual numbers: a $350,000 home’s promised property tax relief amounts to roughly $474 a year — a marginal savings purchased at the cost of gutting school funding. He says he’s tried and failed to find any rationale that would justify his opponent’s vote for the bill.
00:44:15 The Rainy Day Fund Analogy: Sitting on a Surplus While It Pours
- Scott’s framing, which Neal embraces: touting a budget surplus while people can’t afford NIPSCO and child care vouchers get frozen is like sitting on savings while your family goes hungry — and Indiana is doing exactly that with its rainy day fund while it’s actively pouring on Hoosiers.
00:45:18 Are Voters Connecting the Dots on Trump, RFK Jr., and Braun?
- Scott asks whether voters link national and state Republican policy to their own hardships. Neal shares three doorstep encounters: a lifelong Republican furious about the Iran war after being promised no more wars; a Senate Bill 1 critic who wants a nonexistent third party (Neal’s response: there are only two choices on the ballot); and a retired teacher who clearly understood the education funding fight but felt unrepresented by either party.
00:47:36 How Democrats Set Themselves Apart from Corruption on Both Sides
- Scott raises Indianapolis’ Mayor Hogsett and Lake County’s own history of Democratic corruption as a complicating factor. Neal’s answer: stay disciplined on message and platform, avoid negative ads and online arguments that derail focus, and keep returning to concrete stakes like Senate Bill 1 and what specific opponents voted for.
- He stresses civility and direct constituent engagement — he personally responds to non-abusive emails and calls people back — while also arguing Democrats need more internal solidarity, contrasting it with how Republicans close ranks even through their own infighting (citing Senate leadership churn around Rod Bray).
00:51:37 The Locked-Out Workers and the Hypocrisy of Marching With Them
- Neal calls out Republicans who voted to strip union protections and then showed up to march in solidarity with the locked-out USW Local 7-1 workers — a contradiction he finds hard to stomach even acknowledging the union’s official nonpartisan stance.
00:52:59 Does Nick’s Opponent Actually Talk to Constituents?
- Scott asks whether Neal’s opponent, incumbent Julie Olthoff, holds town halls. Neal says he’s aware of one candidate forum before the primary and a parade appearance, but no town hall — and argues that voting record transparency, not attack ads, is what actually builds trust with constituents.
00:54:45 Closing: Where to Find and Support Nick Neal
- Campaign: votenickneal.com, with a Facebook page and an ActBlue donation link accessible from the site. Email: nick@votenickneal.com.
- Upcoming events: a town hall August 27th for St. John Democrats at the library; a “Cigars and Conversations” fundraiser August 25th at Karma Cigar Bar in Merrillville; continued canvassing through the district this month.
- Sunday’s HoosLeft This Week guests: Lafayette-area progressive organizer Erin Moon-Walker and Statehouse District 38 candidate Nate Stout.
