SUMMARY:
HoosLeft sits down with the full board of directors of We The Hoosiers — Board Chair John McGlothlin, Treasurer Zoe Bardon, and Secretary Sarah Kissel — an alumni-led group formed to protect free speech, academic freedom, and shared governance at Indiana University. The guests walk through a timeline of concerns under President Pamela Whitten’s administration: the legislature’s move to replace elected trustee seats with gubernatorial appointees, the override of IU’s own search committee process in hiring Whitten, the suspension of a professor over his support for a Palestinian solidarity group, a canceled art exhibit, a student encampment met with state police and snipers, faculty no-confidence votes answered with a raise and a contract extension, a new “intellectual diversity” complaint law with a real chilling effect on campus speech, threats to the Kinsey Institute, hundreds of cut degree programs, and a university expansion into defense-tech research even as the humanities get squeezed. The panel situates all of this within a decades-long conservative project to reshape higher education, pushes back on the framing of universities as businesses, and closes with concrete ways alumni, students, and ordinary Hoosiers can push back.
We The Hoosiers: https://www.wethehoosiers.com/
HoosLeft: https://hoosleft.us
Progressive Indiana Network: https://progressiveindiana.net
WHAT’S INSIDE:
00:00:00 Introduction and Welcoming We The Hoosiers
Scott opens on IU football’s on-field success set against an administration eroding free speech, tenure, diversity initiatives, and degree programs, then welcomes the board of We The Hoosiers: Board Chair John McGlothlin, Treasurer Zoe Bardon, and Secretary Sarah Kissel.
00:03:51 A Timeline of Concerns: Degree Cuts and the Shift to Appointed Trustees
Sarah traces the group’s roots to the cutting of roughly 200 degree programs and growing statehouse interference with shared governance; John explains that language slipped into Indiana’s May 2025 budget bill converted the three remaining alumni-elected trustee seats to gubernatorial appointments, a move Governor Braun made as an election for one of those seats was already underway.
00:08:19 An Overridden Search: Hiring Pamela Whitten
Scott and John revisit the board’s 2021 decision to override its own presidential search committee to hire Pamela Whitten, citing law professor Steve Sanders’ questioning of the search process and his finding that normal procedural norms weren’t followed.
00:10:22 Zoe’s Years at IU: COVID, a Passed-Over Provost, and Free-Speech Flashpoints
Zoe describes starting at IU in 2020 under the pandemic, admiring the COVID-era leadership of Provost Lauren Robel (passed over for the presidency), and the early suspicion around Whitten’s arrival, including her record of union-busting in Georgia. She then connects three flashpoints from her senior year: the disciplining of political science professor Abdulkader Sinno over his support for the Palestine Solidarity Committee, the Eskenazi Museum’s cancellation of a Samia Halaby retrospective, and the pro-Palestine encampment, which was met by state police and snipers stationed atop the student union, and after which she had friends who were arrested.
00:16:36 No Confidence, a Raise, a Bonus, and Locked Doors
John and Zoe note that both the IU Bloomington and IU South Bend faculty senates voted no confidence in Whitten, while the board responded in February 2025 by extending her contract five years with a 20% raise; Zoe calls the roughly $100,000 bonus she cites out-of-touch given the community’s hardship — reported bonuses have actually run even higher, as much as $250,000. Sarah adds that during the Dunn Meadow protests, faculty and students found Whitten’s office building locked to them — something a professor of decades told her had never happened before.
00:21:18 Senate Enrolled Act 202 and the “Intellectual Diversity” Complaint Line
Scott and John discuss the 2024 Holcomb-era state law that opened a complaint line against professors for “intellectual diversity” violations, quoting the AAUP’s objection that pluralism can’t be mandated by politics; John cites professor Ben Robinson’s censure and an unnamed professor who was let go despite an internal review finding no defensible reason.
00:27:17 The Jessica Adams Case
Scott names the case he had in mind: social work lecturer Jessica Adams, suspended under an SEA 202 complaint for showing a class slide describing “Make America Great Again” as a form of covert white supremacy, placed under observation, and ultimately not renewed. The Nation covered her removal as well.
00:28:22 Threats to the Kinsey Institute and the Politics of Research
Zoe, a former gender studies major, describes the state targeting the Kinsey Institute and gender studies broadly, with grad students — many mid-dissertation and reliant on its archive — leading the fight to keep it on the Bloomington campus. The Board of Trustees ultimately voted to preserve it using a workaround, a decision Zoe says got reframed as Whitten’s own idea; Scott ties the fight to Christian-nationalist political pressure in Indianapolis over gender and sexuality research.
00:34:25 “Western Civilization,” the Jacobs School, and the Useless-Degree Myth
Scott argues it’s ironic that the same voices invoking “Western civilization” are defunding the liberal-arts discussions that tradition depends on; he and John point to the internationally ranked Jacobs School of Music, the Kinsey Institute, and the Lilly Library as IU strengths now treated as liabilities, while vocational and applied-science programs (Ivy Tech, Purdue engineering) have their own valuable but distinct lane.
00:39:20 Liberal Arts, AI, and the Soft-Skills Argument
Zoe argues a liberal-arts foundation is especially valuable as AI reshapes the job market; Scott notes his own computer science degree is already obsolete as AI writes code, making broad, adaptable education the safer long-term bet.
00:40:30 The Commission for Higher Education’s Opaque Cuts
Sarah describes the state’s Commission for Higher Education eliminating roughly 200 degree programs from IU without publishing the metrics or reasoning behind the list.
00:42:41 Defense Tech at Crane and an AAUP Audit That Found No Budget Crisis
Scott notes IU just opened a new Applied Research Center the same week, tying it to the Applied Research Institute’s work with NSWC Crane and Purdue Research Foundation — framed as “defense tech” but, in Scott’s words, war- and weapons-making; John then cites an outside financial audit commissioned by the Bloomington AAUP chapter that found IU’s finances and credit rating strong, meaning the real issue isn’t a lack of money but administration claiming a growing share of it while students, faculty, and staff get a shrinking share.
00:45:48 A 60-Year Culture War: Reagan, Berkeley, and “Universities Are Not Businesses”
Scott traces the dismantling of public universities to a 60-plus-year project dating to Reagan’s reaction against Berkeley student protests; Sarah pushes back hard on treating universities as businesses, arguing they serve a civic role that can’t be measured by corporate metrics.
00:49:51 So What Can Hoosiers Do?
Scott asks what levers alumni, students, faculty, and football fans alike actually have, and the three guests answer in turn: John says the group’s strongest current ask is simply making noise so the administration knows alumni are watching, and recounts an earlier, so-far-unsuccessful push modeled on 1980s Harvard students who escrowed donations until the university divested from apartheid South Africa; Zoe points students toward campus coalitions like People’s 2030, supporting student journalism (the IDS), and networking with alumni willing to help; Sarah closes by urging everyone to contact legislators and trustees directly and to find We The Hoosiers on Facebook, LinkedIn, and at wethehoosiers.com.
00:58:07 Closing Thanks and Show Outro









