Thank you The Steady State, M Hope, and many others for tuning into our live video! Join us for our next live video in the app.
SUMMARY:
In the second installment of a special roundtable series (following last week's episode on the multi-front war on public education), Scott is joined by Stuart Mora, founder of the Indiana Organizing Project and a former immigration law firm staffer, and Miguel Avila, a Mexican immigrant and organizer who spent nine months in ICE detention at Clay County Jail. The conversation covers this weekend's statewide Weekend of Public Witness at Miami Correctional Facility — Indiana's largest ICE detention site — and the broader machinery around it: the 287(g) agreements turning local jails into federal profit centers, the human toll on families with U.S. citizen children, firsthand accounts of retaliation and dehumanizing conditions from inside Miami Correctional, the private-prison profit motive driving expansion, the purely economic case against mass deportation, and the strategic question of how to talk about what's happening without losing the persuadable middle. It closes with concrete ways to get involved and a roundup of Indiana organizations doing the work.
Progressive Indiana Network: https://progressiveindiana.net
HoosLeft: https://hoosleft.us
Indiana Organizing Project: https://indianaorganizing.org/
Indiana Aid: https://www.indianaaid.org/
WHAT’S INSIDE:
00:00:21 Introduction: A New Roundtable Series and Tonight’s Immigration Focus
- Scott frames tonight as the second in a special roundtable series on topical issues affecting Hoosiers, following last week’s discussion on the multi-front war on public education (available at progressiveindiana.net). Next week: a discussion on democratic socialism.
- Tonight’s focus: Indiana’s role as a Midwest hub for ICE arrests, local police being pulled into federal immigration enforcement, deplorable detention conditions, the financial incentives behind it all, and the human toll.
00:01:32 Support the Show
- HoosLeft and Progressive Indiana Network don’t paywall content — support at progressiveindiana.net sustains the project. Social handles: @hoosleft.us on Bluesky, Instagram, and Threads; @HoosLeft on Facebook, TikTok, and YouTube; PIN is @pinindiana on Bluesky and TikTok.
00:02:28 Welcome Stuart Mora and the Indiana Organizing Project
- Stuart Mora returns to the show. He founded the Indiana Organizing Project on March 1st of this year after several years working at Muñoz Legal, an Indianapolis immigration law firm, supporting detained immigrants and their families. He transitioned to full-time organizing in February, now supporting ICE detainees and families statewide and leading the campaign to end ICE detention at Miami Correctional Facility.
00:04:27 This Weekend’s Public Witness: Scale, Faith, and Reframing ‘Protest’
- Following May 16th’s statewide day of action (29 coordinated actions), this weekend’s Weekend of Public Witness spans Friday through Sunday with 59 confirmed actions across the state, largely faith-led.
- Scott and Stuart discuss the biblical mandate (Old and New Testament alike) to welcome the stranger. Stuart explains the deliberate choice of “public witness” over “protest”: living out shared values and faith publicly, inviting disagreement into conversation rather than confrontation, on the premise that most people — including Trump voters — don’t actually understand how complicated and non-binary immigration status really is. Scott notes “protest” carries baggage that “public witness” sidesteps, without softening the substance.
00:09:29 A Neighbor’s Story: A Detained Father, a Pregnant Mother, Traumatized Kids
- Stuart shares a story from a family in his own Indianapolis neighborhood: a U.S. citizen mother, three U.S. citizen children (including a newborn), and a legal permanent resident father — general manager of a laundromat, in the country since childhood — detained for over six months with no warning, mid-home-purchase.
- Miguel Avila joins mid-story. Stuart continues: a four-year-old talking about suicide, a five-year-old breaking down over “family” discussions at kindergarten, and a newborn amid it all. Stuart connects this to the federal government manufacturing “illegal” status out of people with valid legal standing — TPS revocations, valid asylum seekers, longtime legal permanent residents.
- Scott responds bluntly: decades of Republican “pro-family, pro-life” rhetoric exposed as political theater.
00:13:17 Meet Miguel Avila: Nine Months in ICE Detention
- Miguel introduces himself: a Mexican immigrant, 22 years in Indiana, incarcerated for nine months in ICE detention. He calls the experience indescribable — tremendous stress, anxiety, mixed feelings — and modern detention centers as “nothing but modern concentration camps.” Even after being bailed, he was held 13 additional days for no stated reason, part of a deliberate effort to morally, spiritually, and physically break detainees down.
00:14:58 I Hesitate to Ask You to Talk About It
- Scott checks in with Miguel about re-traumatization before pressing further. Miguel says talking about it, however hard, is part of how he copes and heals — even knowing he may never fully recover.
00:15:33 Inside Clay County Jail and the 287(g) Pipeline
- Miguel was held at Clay County Jail in Brazil, Indiana — nine and a half months with no sunlight, no fresh air, only artificial light, losing all track of time. He calls Miami Correctional the worst facility, with Clay close behind.
- Scott explains 287(g) agreements: local police and county jails contracting with the federal government to act as ICE agents, marketed as a financial boon for cash-strapped local governments (especially post-Braun property tax cuts) — “the cost of your humanity,” as Scott puts it.
00:18:16 Clark County, Do Something Southern Indiana, and the Roofers Who Didn’t Come Home
- Stuart highlights Clark County — one of only 5 of Indiana’s 92 counties housing ICE detainees in county jail via a U.S. Marshal Service contract, about 60 beds — and the local organization Do Something Southern Indiana pushing back at sheriff budget hearings under the banner “not in our name.”
- Scott cites a WAVE (Louisville) news report: at least 28 people arrested in a Clark County operation July 8th–9th, including a description of an abandoned van with workers’ lunches and roofing knee-pads still inside — a family that lost a father who simply never came home from a normal workday.
00:22:34 TPS Explained: Haitian Community and the Human Cost of Revocation
- Stuart defines Temporary Protected Status: a legal status renewed roughly every two years, requiring no more than one misdemeanor conviction, with no direct pathway to residency or citizenship. 350,000 Haitians nationally had TPS revoked on the premise that Haiti is now safe — which Stuart disputes directly, recounting a priest’s account of gang violence and a deadly church shooting there just years ago. Indiana has a significant Haitian community, including many in healthcare and home care roles.
00:24:58 Desensitization and the Profit Motive Behind Detention
- Miguel argues the public has become desensitized to ICE operations rotating through cities, and that the “arresting criminals” framing was never really the point — detention capacity keeps expanding because every filled bed is revenue. He warns the next targets, once immigrants aren’t enough to fill beds, will be homeless people, people needing mental health or Social Security support, and LGBTQ people. He also describes hearing riot-gear testing and low-flying aircraft drowning out a vigil outside Miami Correctional that same day.
00:29:09 Homelessness, RFK Jr., and Delaney Hall’s Billion-Dollar Contract
- Scott connects the dots: Indiana criminalized homelessness this year, and RFK Jr.’s HHS is pushing to reinstitutionalize disabled people rather than fund community-based care — both feeding the same private detention infrastructure.
- Stuart cites Delaney Hall in New Jersey: a 15-year, $1 billion contract with GEO Group, illustrating the scale of money locked into these systems regardless of whether beds are actually needed.
00:30:00 A Letter From Miami Correctional: Omar’s Account
- Stuart reads a letter from a recently released Miami Correctional detainee (Omar), a two-time kidney transplant recipient and stroke survivor: horrific food, medical neglect, a stabbing after security stopped confiscating razors, and a facility that profits from voluntary departure forms and commissary fees.
00:32:15 Are These Concentration Camps? Scott’s Dad, and Miguel’s Answer
- Scott recounts his Republican father’s resistance to the term “concentration camp.” Miguel affirms the comparison: modern versions swap tattooed numbers for plastic bracelets, and swap forced labor for making families work themselves to exhaustion just to support detainees financially — psychological torture including sunlight and vitamin D deprivation designed to break even the strongest will.
00:34:02 What Miguel Is Hearing Now: Retaliation and Racial Slurs From Guards
- Miguel relays a fresh call from a detainee’s wife: retaliatory solitary confinement after contact with a lawyer or the ACLU, and guards randomly pepper-spraying cells at night simply to justify canister usage reports.
- Stuart corroborates: detainees reporting racial slurs from guards so extreme they were inventing new ones, and a guard threatening to pour boiling water on a detainee praying on his knees.
00:36:29 Untrained and Unleashed: How ICE Hiring Has Changed
- Scott argues ICE’s massive funding increase has led to rapid, low-bar hiring with inadequate training compared to pre-Trump standards, resulting in documented public misconduct in Chicago and Minnesota — with presumably worse conditions behind closed doors in detention facilities.
00:38:00 ‘You Need to Care Less’: The Medical Crisis and the ACLU Lawsuit
- Stuart credits Indianapolis Star journalist Kristine Phillips’s July reporting on Miami Correctional’s chaotic, understaffed rollout under Governor Braun’s administration — hundreds or thousands of missed medication doses, and a former nurse told by facility leadership, verbatim, “you need to care less” when she raised the lack of medical staffing.
00:39:27 The ACLU Lawsuit and Deaths That Don’t Count
- Scott details an ACLU lawsuit over a detainee denied seizure medication, going into a seizure after nearly a year seizure-free — the ACLU calling the facility’s conduct “cruel and unconstitutional.” Two people have died in custody there so far, and Scott notes people released while gravely ill don’t count toward official death-in-custody statistics if they die shortly after release.
00:41:05 The Campaign’s Real Goal and the Purely Economic Case for Caring
- Stuart frames the realistic campaign win: since Miami Correctional’s ICE contract is two years and Indiana is one year in, blocking contract renewal — not necessarily immediate closure — would be a genuine victory, and the recent gubernatorial call for investigation is an encouraging sign. He also flags forthcoming litigation and settlement costs the state hasn’t priced into its “profitable” framing.
- Scott pivots to the economic argument for skeptics: a Fortune magazine analysis found roughly 28% of direct healthcare workers were immigrants as of 2022, and losing that workforce (tied to Project 2025’s broader aims) pushes caregiving burdens back onto women. On construction: for every six undocumented male workers pushed out of a local labor market, one U.S.-born male worker also loses his job, as stalled projects ripple outward.
00:46:43 Business Owners and Restaurant Jobs Lost to Deportation
- Stuart notes many deportees are themselves business owners employing others. Miguel, drawing on 15–18 years in the restaurant industry, illustrates: losing 3 of 6 back-of-house workers to arrest can shutter a restaurant entirely, costing the roughly 20 front-of-house staff (servers, bartenders, hosts) their jobs too — immigrants create jobs, they don’t just fill them.
00:48:41 It Can Happen Here: The Boiling Frog
- Scott invokes the boiling-frog metaphor: dramatic changes normalized through gradual escalation. The existence of concentration camps in America would have sounded absurd 30–40 years ago — and now it’s happening.
00:49:33 Naming It Carefully: Concentration Camps, Due Process, and Strategic Language
- Stuart unpacks the term precisely: a concentration camp, by definition, is rounding up people without due process — and he no longer believes U.S. immigration courts (run by the DOJ’s executive branch, which has purged judges deemed too lenient, even fair-minded ones) meet that bar.
- Strategically, though, he avoids the term publicly because it triggers Holocaust associations that can shut down persuadable listeners. Citing advice from a communications professional (”show them, don’t tell them”), he leads with concrete stories instead — while remaining unambiguous that immigration courts are no longer functioning as real due process.
00:52:05 The Purpose of the Suffering: Coercion and Third-Country Deportation
- Scott connects Omar’s letter to a broader purpose: unbearable conditions designed to coerce “voluntary” departure — sometimes to a third country with no connection to the detainee at all, including deportations to parts of Africa where people may not even speak the local language.
00:53:01 A Brownsburg Family: Deported to the One Country He Couldn’t Legally Go To
- Stuart shares a case soon to run in the Indianapolis Star: a Brownsburg father of five U.S. citizen children, in the country since 2001, with withholding of removal from Guinea since 2007 (meaning he cannot legally be deported there). Detained in June with no notice, shuffled through possible destinations, he was deported to Ghana, held briefly, then sent onward to Guinea — the one country barred to him — forcing him to immediately flee to Sierra Leone, now stateless. He was detained while planning his community’s 4th of July picnic; his family calls him a patriot.
00:55:41 Birthright Citizenship Under Threat: Greg Bovino and 100 Million Deportations
- Scott describes attendees at a recent Thorntown rally and the “remigration” movement arguing that American citizen children of certain immigrants shouldn’t be citizens at all — specifically, anyone whose family arrived after 1965. He names Greg Bovino, keynote speaker at what Scott calls a “modern day Klan rally” earlier in August, who has stated a goal of deporting 100 million people, and calls the citizenship-revocation framing what it is: ethnic cleansing.
00:56:53 Miguel: A Nation of Immigrants and the Distraction of Social Media
- Miguel argues the country’s immigrant origins are undeniable history, and that social media-driven distraction keeps people from recognizing the pattern repeating itself.
- Scott names the phenomenon directly: an intentional, partly foreign-driven information war designed to turn Americans against one another — and it’s succeeding.
00:59:04 What Haven’t We Asked? Detention’s Expanding Target List
- Asked what’s been missed, Stuart reiterates: ICE detention infrastructure being built for immigrants now will inevitably expand — to U.S. citizens stripped of citizenship, to Muslims and trans people (per Micah Beckwith’s stated goals), the homeless, the mentally ill, and already, partially, political opponents. He connects his own organizing directly to self-preservation: he, Miguel, and Scott could all plausibly become targets under a trajectory he compares to Putin’s Russia.
01:00:40 Fighting for Yourself, Not Just Your Neighbor
- Scott reframes the appeal for the purely self-interested: even setting humanity aside, these are economically productive neighbors, and Indiana’s new law requiring schools to admit ICE agents can traumatize children of any background — the ripple effects touch places people don’t expect.
01:01:54 Miguel: We Outnumber Them, and a Letter From Gabriel Olivares
- Miguel calls for continued awareness-raising and preparation, noting good people vastly outnumber “the 1% of the oligarchy.” He then reads a letter (shared with permission) from Gabriel Eugenio Olivares, released from prison in June 2026 after 23 years for a crime he says he didn’t commit, now awaiting deportation to Argentina — fractured shoulder from a fall, medical care denied, still waiting weeks later. Miguel notes this is one of 748 cases he’s tracking.
01:05:02 The Inhumanity of It All
- Scott says he cannot put himself in the mindset of guards and policymakers who see this as acceptable. Stuart attributes it to top-down dehumanization — treating detainees as fundamentally “other” — and finds hope in community organizing and turnout.
01:06:16 Closing: Landing Page for Events and Shoutouts to Partner Organizations
- Organization shoutouts: Indiana Aid (direct detainee support), the Indiana Undocumented Youth Alliance (IUYA), Do Something Southern Indiana, and Fuerza Unida in Fort Wayne.
01:08:24 Miguel’s Organization Shoutouts and Farewell
- After a brief connection hiccup, Miguel adds his own list: IUYA, COIN (Coalition for Our Immigrant Neighbors), Cosecha, Freedom for Immigrants, and Calor Humano — describing an informal, statewide coordinating support network largely improvised on the fly.
01:11:03 Scott’s Wrap-Up and Sign-Off
- Scott thanks both guests, previews the show notes (organization links, Weekend of Public Witness details), and closes with standard show information: full episode available on Facebook and YouTube immediately, podcast and notes publish the next morning at progressiveindiana.net, support via paid subscription (with an explicit ask to prioritize supporting immigrant-aid organizations first), and details for Sunday’s HoosLeft This Week.
